Article of the week

21 Jul, 2019
, Source:

An excellent, thoughtful article on the urgent need to diffuse polarized debates to more civil, open dialogue with room for differences –  HL

Preserving Civility in Vaccine Policy Discourse: A Way Forward

Gregory A. Poland, MD; Jon C. Tilburt, MD; Edgar K. Marcuse, MD        Published in JAMA    16 July 2019   

Vaccine policy-making meetings, advisory committees, and legislative hearings at the local, state, and national levels have become increasingly uncivil.  Many who object to vaccines have resorted to shouting, threats, and other disruptive behaviors.1 These  behaviors erode the premise of civil society and undermine the goals of most vaccine-hesitant persons,  who are thoughtful and law abiding. Civil skepticism in public discussions about vaccine policy can  lead to productive discussion. The science of vaccinology, like all science, has uncertainties; applying science in policy entails value judgments, and people can disagree on the implications of scientific evidence.  Skepticism reminds all individuals that intellectual humility is important and reinforces the value of  democratic debate and transparent procedure.

Good Public Health Policy 
Good public health vaccine policy results from the interaction between science and values. Good science is the foundation for good policy. But science is complex, the evidence is sometimes conflicting, and absolute certainty is elusive. Transparent presentation of the science is imperative to sustain public confidence, requiring open discussion of how best to balance protection of public health with individual freedom. All public health policies ultimately depend on a broad societal consensus for support. Most people still support immunizations, but a vocal and disruptive group of vaccine skeptics have adopted uncivil tactics, thereby disrupting and bypassing the healthy, transparent debate and democratic procedure of US vaccine policy. These skeptics threaten individual and public health, as well as civil engagement…     

read  full article   



This entry was posted on Sunday, July 21st, 2019 at 10:03 am and is filed under Blog.

Videos Video archive

Emilie Karafillakis, research fellow for the Vaccine Confidence Project, speaks to France 24 about the rising anti-vaccination sentiment that is rising throughout Europe, especially in France where a recent study revealed 1 in 3 citizens believe vaccines are unsafe.

In this episode of Take as Directed, J. Stephen Morrison speaks with Dr. Heidi Larson on why vaccine confidence is currently in crisis, and how this has fueled outbreaks such as measles and the persistence of polio in Afghanistan and Pakistan.

Prof Larson discusses vaccine hesitancy and its implications across global health in this webinar.

Literature Literature archive

HC Maltezou, C Ledda, V Rapisarda 2019 Vaccine Vol 37(32): 4419-4658
Sabahelzain MM et al. 2019 PLoS ONE VOl 14 (6): e0213882.
KT Paul, K Loer 2019 Journal of Public Health Policy Volume 40, Issue 2
Subscribe to our mailing list

Click here to go to our GDPR-compliant signup form.

The Vaccine Knowledge Project at the Oxford Vaccine Group